Plumber or Water Damage Company: Who to Call First After a Leak
Call a plumber first only if water is still coming out and you cannot stop it. In every other case, shut off the water, then call a water damage restoration company right away. The plumber fixes the pipe. The restoration crew removes the water that already got into your floors and walls and dries the house so it does not turn into mold. Most leaks need both, often on the same day. For water damage anywhere in Long Island or New York City, call (516) 620-5400. A person answers, and we tell you on the call when our crew will be there.
The short version
| Situation | Call first | Then |
|---|---|---|
| Pipe still spraying, you cannot find the shutoff | Plumber (or shut the main valve yourself) | Water damage company |
| Water is off, floor or ceiling is wet | Water damage company | Plumber to repair the pipe |
| Toilet or sewer backup | Water damage company (sewage is contaminated) | Plumber to clear the line |
| Water heater burst | Shut its water and power, then water damage company | Plumber to replace the heater |
| Slow leak found behind a wall | Plumber to find and fix it | Water damage company to check for hidden moisture and mold |
What a plumber does
A plumber stops and repairs the source. That means fixing a burst supply line, a cracked fitting, a failed water heater, a leaking toilet seal or a clogged sewer line. Plumbers are the right call when you cannot stop the water, or when the cause is still unknown.
What a plumber usually does not do is deal with the water that already escaped. Once the pipe is fixed, the wet carpet, soaked drywall and damp subfloor are still there.
What a water damage restoration company does
A restoration crew handles everything the water touched:
- Water extraction. Pumps and truck or portable extractors pull standing water out of carpet, pad and floors.
- Finding hidden water. Moisture meters and thermal cameras show how far the water traveled inside walls, under flooring and into the floor below.
- Removing what cannot be saved. Wet carpet pad, the bottom of soaked drywall and wet insulation often have to come out.
- Drying. Dehumidifiers and air movers run for several days, with moisture readings each day until the materials are dry.
- Mold prevention. Damp materials can start growing mold within days if they are not dried, which is why speed matters.
- Paperwork. Photos, moisture logs and a scope of work for your insurance claim.
You can read more about what happens on the first visit in our guide to water extraction and how long drying usually takes.
Why waiting for the plumber can cost you
The most common mistake we see is a homeowner who waits for the plumber, gets the pipe fixed, and then mops up and hopes the rest dries on its own. Water does not stay where you can see it. It wicks up drywall, runs under baseboards and soaks into the subfloor. A floor can feel dry on top while the wood underneath is still wet.
Two things go wrong when wet materials sit:
- Damage spreads. Hardwood cups, laminate swells, drywall softens and ceilings below start to stain or sag.
- Mold starts. Mold needs moisture and time. A finished basement or a wall cavity that stays damp is the perfect place for it.
Insurance can also become harder. Many policies expect you to take reasonable steps to limit damage. Starting extraction and drying quickly, with photos and readings, helps show your adjuster you did that.
What to do in the first hour
- Shut off the water. Find the main valve, usually where the water line enters the house near the meter, often in the basement or a utility closet. In an apartment, call the super or building management right away.
- Turn off power to wet areas at the breaker, but only if you can reach the panel without standing in water.
- Take photos and video of the water, the source and anything damaged before you move things.
- Move what you can off wet floors: rugs, boxes, electronics, furniture legs onto foil or blocks.
- Call both if needed. You can call the plumber and the restoration company at the same time. The crews do not get in each other's way, and the drying can start while the repair is scheduled.
Special cases
Sewage or toilet backups. Water from a sewer line or toilet is contaminated. Do not clean it with household tools. The area needs to be extracted, cleaned and disinfected by a trained crew, and porous materials it touched usually have to go. See our sewage cleanup service.
Leaks from upstairs in an apartment. In New York City buildings, the leak is often in a neighbor's unit or the building's own pipes. Tell the super or management right away and document everything. Our guide to a leak from an upstairs neighbor covers who is responsible.
Flooded basements. If the water came from rain, groundwater or a failed sump pump, a plumber may not be the right call at all. Start with our flooded basement cleanup guide.
Who pays for what
Your homeowners policy may treat the two jobs differently. Many policies cover sudden water damage to your home and belongings but not the repair or replacement of the pipe or appliance that failed. Slow leaks over a long time and outside flooding are often excluded or need separate coverage. Read your policy, call your agent, and keep every receipt. We work directly with your insurance company and your adjuster, and our photos and moisture logs give them what they need. Our step by step guide on filing a water damage claim walks through it.
Call us when the water is off
Aqua-Pro Restoration is a water damage restoration company based in Melville, serving Nassau, Suffolk and New York City. We extract the water, find what is hidden, dry the house with daily readings and document everything for your claim. Call (516) 620-5400, any hour. A person answers, and we tell you on the call when our crew will be there.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I call a plumber or a water damage company first?
If water is still flowing and you cannot shut it off, call a plumber first or shut the main valve yourself. Once the water is stopped, call a water damage restoration company the same day, because wet drywall, insulation and flooring keep soaking up water until it is extracted and dried.
Can a plumber dry out my house after a leak?
Most plumbers repair the pipe or fixture and leave. Drying a house takes extraction equipment, dehumidifiers, air movers and moisture meters to find water hidden in walls and floors. That is the job of a water damage restoration crew.
Will insurance pay for both the plumber and the water damage cleanup?
It depends on your policy and the cause. Many homeowners policies cover sudden water damage to the house, but not the repair of the pipe or appliance that failed. We work directly with your insurance company and your adjuster, and we document the damage with photos and moisture readings.
Need Emergency Restoration Now?
Our IICRC-certified team responds 24/7 across NYC, Long Island, NJ & CT.
Found this useful? Add Aqua-Pro as a preferred source on Google and our guides show up first when you search.
Water in your home right now? Call us.
A real person answers 24/7. IICRC-certified crews, insurance documentation included.
